kauricat (kauricat) wrote,
kauricat
kauricat

  • Mood:

Portal 2: User Generated Rooms

Portal 2 has a really nifty thing you can do. You can design your own testing rooms and share them with other people! I tried some user-developed rooms today and I found out something about myself that I did not realize when I played the original game.

I only really enjoy certain kinds of puzzles in this game. Elements that I do not like include:

1) Timed anything - timed walls that only move into position for seconds before retreating, timed doors that only open for a few precious seconds, etc. I don't like any of that. Any time you hit a button and it start clicking, I immediately do not like it. Probably because I am not that adept at shooting my portals with precision, and I run out of time every time. It's not fun for me to do that over and over until I get it exactly right.

2) Rooms with very few portal-able surfaces. I really don't like that black crap or the metallic stuff or anything else I cannot shoot a portal through.

3) Shooting portals in mid-air when there is very little time. I find that on really long jumps, I'm okay. When I'm in a back and forth loop so I have plenty of time to orient myself, I'm okay. When it's a split-second "Do it now or lose your chance" type of thing, I don't like it.

4) Those laser grills. Not the individual shocky lasers, but the ones that if you touch them you die. Do not want.

Things I do like:

1) Light bridges

2) Light tunnels

3) Aerial Faith Plates (but in moderation)

4) Stationary portal surfaces (like when you need to jump out from a slanted panel)

5) Repulsion gel and Propulsion gel

6) Emancipation grids (used in moderation)

7) Finding a weighted cube or ball and putting on a button or in a fitted receptacle

8) Lasers that you have to redirect, through a portal, a cube, or both

9) The cubes that redirect lasers


Which is why it broke my heart when someone I know designed a room and I really did not like it. It was made up of timed panels, mostly black walls, and a couple of places where you had to shoot your portal right away or you missed your chance. All things I don't like. And there were some laser grills in there too. Avoidable, but still there. It really brought home to me how different people prefer different things in their game.

I tried another room that had been rated highly by others, and I LOVED it. You had to do a lot of thinking to figure out how to solve it, there were no timers, there were no laser grills, there were lots of portal-able surfaces, and the whole object of the test revolved around finding three cubes and a ball and putting them where they went. Like it was made for me.

It was just interesting to me. Also kind of disappointing that I had to leave my friend a critique that was not that great. I think she designed a good room, for the most part. Just not one that I find fun, mainly because of the timer and the jumps that don't allow (for me) enough time to shoot the required portals.

Maybe eventually I will try my hand at making a room. Probably not, though. I much prefer playing them to trying to create them.
Tags: dw, portal
Subscribe

  • Something Fun

    Most people are semi-familiar with the children's book, "Goodnight, Moon." I did not know until just now that someone had created, " Goodnight,…

  • Antikythera out of Lego

    I'm not sure this is right - wasn't one of the gears elliptical to correct for Earth's orbit?

  • (no subject)

    Whoa. Can this be true, and if so, did Thomas Seymour and/or Robert Dudley have any clue??…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 2 comments